Zhejiang University reply “net red paper”: will not reduce academic standards

Original title: network packet can be considered strictly academic papers Yin Zhengyi Zhejiang University said it would shut

Beijing News News recently, Zhejiang University, published “outstanding cultural achievements recognized network (for Trial Implementation)” ( Hereinafter referred to as “measures”), which provides in the media and its “two micro-end” published excellent net text, according to the release platform and the level of communication can be identified as the domestic authority, level, core and other academic journals, Awards.

The “approach” one, immediately lead to hot. In this regard, Zhejiang University responded to the media that identified excellent network culture results will not reduce the academic standards, the results required by the Committee of Experts strict assessment.

According to the “approach”, excellent online cultural achievements include excellent original articles published in newspapers, television, Internet or broadcast, with extensive network communication. , Audio and video, animation and other works, the original number of words should be no less than 1000 words.

For how to identify the results of excellent network culture, Zhejiang University has made a division of the declaration level, according to the release platform and the level of the two most basic identified indicators, divided into three levels. For example, the first level can be identified equivalent to the domestic authoritative academic journals published in the “People’s Daily”, “Guangming Daily” and “seeking” magazine published three media, and the formation of a major network of communication s work. “Significant” that the work was not less than 20 mainstream media and its website, “two micro-end” and important commercial sites and its “two micro-end” published, reproduced.

At the same time, the “approach” also made the scope of the media made the provisions of the central level newspapers, television for the “People’s Daily”, “Global Times”, “half talk” and other nine media; Including the “China Education”, “China Science”, “Beijing News” and other influential media, as well as provincial and municipal party newspapers, radio, etc .; important business portal, including Sina, Sohu and other portals, and its ” Two micro-end “.

Zhejiang University said it would not reduce the academic standards

the “approach” one, immediately caused a hot online, many articles with “net text 100,000 + can be academic papers” as the title , That the “approach” will be “media click” and the academic value of academic papers equal, easily lead to academic “step backward”; also supporters feel that the new regulation of Zhejiang University, the impact of the existing single academic evaluation system, is the reform Innovation, courage, worthy of promotion.

In this regard, Zhejiang University, the relevant departments to respond to the media said the introduction of outstanding network of cultural achievements that approach to explore the humanities and social sciences research results show diversification. Humanities and Social Sciences research can not be far from reality, that the outstanding network culture results, is to answer in the Internet age, how to use new means of communication to expand the outstanding academic achievement of this important issue, that excellent network culture results will not reduce the academic standards.

Zhejiang University said that the network culture is excellent online culture original works, universities should encourage and guide the division to produce a high level of results. The school hopes to actively explore and try in this area, and in the specific work to be perfected. To meet the “approach” in the basic conditions of the results of the declaration, by the Committee of Experts to seek truth from facts, rigorous scientific attitude, uphold the serious academic traditions, academic norms and academic standards for rigorous review, to see if it can be assessed as the corresponding academic results.

Interrupted

Zhejiang University teachers and students

is a lot of outside reading out of context

for “measures,” a Zhejiang University teacher said that the introduction of this provision Not enough thought, some hasty, but the starting point and motivation is good. At the same time, the interpretation of the outside world is very extreme, many are out of context.

“” approach “is not to say that the red thread can be identified as an academic paper, refers to the social issues on public affairs have a study, have profound insights on the article, if the new media platform to produce a major society Influence, and journal papers can be treated equally. “The teacher said.

In his view, “approach” is to encourage scholars to sound in the new media platform, not limited to small circle of culture. Academic journals are small minority communication, circulation, but thousands of copies, tens of thousands of copies. If it is in the network, the new media platform for public affairs, social issues sound, and have a significant social impact, its social spread is broader, higher than the academic papers, bring more social benefits overflow.

“What is the value of something if it does not spread, then what is the value of it? Value is achieved in the process of communication, in the present era, the spread of the broader the better.” He said.

Zhejiang University of a humanities and social science class of professional students told reporters that the humanities and social science for the professional, academic results are relatively difficult, in the academic journals issued more difficult, the new regulations to some extent alleviated Academic pressure. And if the network issued a document can be identified as academic results, then find a job in the resume also look better.

Reporters noted that Zhejiang University’s response to this matter, “approach” aims to explore the humanities and social science research results show diversification. The above-mentioned humanities and social sciencesIndustry students said that his professional more emphasis on practice, many students are also engaged in their own public name, for them, is doing is their results, in fact, with the academic papers are the same.

science and engineering students say they are still more inclined to publish papers in the field of journals, patent applications and other forms, but the new rules for students to provide a new possibility, nothing is not Well, no matter what way, this is a manifestation of their own ability and proof.

The network platform

for the academic article Brush will remove the processing

“approach” that “larger network communication” means that the work is not less than 10 mainstream Media and its website, “two micro-end” and the important commercial website and its “two micro-end” published, reproduced; WeChat public works published, not less than 100,000; headlines published works, read The amount of not less than 400,000.

User suggested that there will be no buy flow, read the amount of reading the situation? How will it be supervised?

In this regard, by the “approach” identified as the central level newspapers, television news media, one of the “Global Times” WeChat on the 16th issued a document, said that in the Global Times WeChat made it easy to come Try the standard; Global Times “10 million +” is not difficult, but forbidden reading for academic articles, once found to delete the amount of brush to delete the article.

How do good online cultural achievements identify?

(a) published in the “People’s Daily”, “Guangming Daily” and “Qiushi” magazine, and the formation of major network communication works, can be declared as equivalent to the domestic authority of academic journals published. (2) in the central level newspapers, television news media published or broadcast, and the formation of a larger network of communication works; in the central media website and its “official microblogging, official WeChat, the official mobile customers (Hereinafter referred to as “two micro-end”), other mainstream media and its website, “two micro-end” and important business portal and its “two micro-end” published, reproduced, and have a significant impact on the formation of a major network Dissemination of works; by the provincial and ministerial level network culture selection awards works can be declared as equivalent to the domestic academic journals published. (3) in the central level newspapers, television news media published or broadcast, and the formation of network communication works; in the central media website and its “two micro”, other mainstream media and its website, “Two micro-end” and important business portal and its “two micro-end” published, reproduced and have a greater impact, the formation of a larger network of works; by the Ministry of Education and the provincial government propaganda department, the provincial education Hall and other bureau level network culture selection reward works, can be declared as equivalent to the domestic core journals published.

major, how does the larger network spread?

(a) major network communication:

works by not less than 20 mainstream media and its website, “two micro-end” and important commercial sites and its “two micro-end” published Reprinted.

(2) larger network communication:

works are not less than 10 mainstream media and its website, “two micro-end” and important commercial website and its “two micro The number of reading works not less than 100,000; headlines published works, reading the amount of not less than 400,000.

Online article into the evaluation of Zhejiang University of non-individual cases

excellent network articles into scientific research, Zhejiang University is not a case.

As the Ministry of Education in 2013 to carry out the campus network culture construction special pilot school Shanghai Jiaotong University, the reporter noted that “Shanghai Jiaotong University ideological and political work briefing [2017] No. 16” mentioned in the pilot Will be excellent network culture into the propaganda ideological work cadre job title evaluation conditions. According to media reports, some colleges and universities in Shanghai has long been the standard as a basis for the evaluation of teachers work. In addition, in 2013, the Ministry of Education, “on the campus network culture construction of the pilot work of the notice” mentioned that the development of excellent network of articles into the scientific research results, as a job (title) evaluation criteria The way. In September 2015, the Ministry of Education promulgated the “Opinions on Strengthening and Improving the Construction of Ideological and Political Work Units in Colleges and Universities”, and actively explored the establishment of excellent network articles in terms of scientific research achievements and job title evaluation. Identification mechanism.

In this year’s Ministry of Education released 2017 work points, once again mentioned: to promote the excellent network culture into scientific research results, job title (title) assessment, evaluation and evaluation conditions.

Academic Achievements Urgent need for third party accreditation procedures

Chinese Academy of Educational Sciences researcher Chu Zhaohui said, where the document is only a form of problems, academic results that urgent need to solve is To establish an independent, professional third party accreditation process.

He said, such asIt is a misunderstanding that the academic achievement is worthwhile in academic journals than in the new media of the network. With academic journals to assess the academic value of this matter itself does not fly, if a person has a deep ideological depth of professional vision, no matter what way the performance is valuable, so the scope of the scope to expand, of course, can not go to another extreme, Based on the amount of read, read the amount of the article to measure the academic value. What is needed is a professional third-party accreditation process, the assessment of academic results, anonymous treatment of the article, the assessment of public opinion, with a reasonable recognition of the academic results identified.

Article By :

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *